

I still love the first stage of Spore, that simple, Pac-Ma- like feedback loop of swimming around a primordial sea on some distant planet, gobbling up bits of vegetation or other equally tiny critters. First though, you’ll need to spend a few billion years evolving from a blob of organic matter in the ocean. Instead, it posits that life is threaded right through our galaxy, and you will get to interact with it. Of course, Spore ignores that last and annoyingly enduring fact. All of it, the whole shebang, the bizarre phenomenon which, so far as we know, only exists on our own planet. Rather than simulating lives plural, as Wright did in games like SimCity and the Sims, Spore simulates Life singular. Spore was the brainchild of gaming icon Will Wright, and as with nearly all of Will Wright’s games, Spore is a life simulation. It’s worth going over that premise again.

I don’t think this criticism is entirely accurate, but there’s a kernel of truth to it that hints at the actual element of Spore that makes it so divisive. One of the most common criticisms of Spore upon release was that it wasn’t a game, but five mini-games stitched together. What the hell happened? Have these people gone mad with nostalgia? Or, and this might be terrifying for some to concede, but were the critics right all along?Īs is so often the case, the answer is more complex than either of these suggestions, hinging largely upon how willing you are to buy into Spore’s premise. That’s the metric of a great game, verging on an excellent game. That’s not even a No Man’s Sky (which I actually think is pretty good, if not 87 percent good). Critics awarded it an average score of 84 percent, according to Metacritic, and were much derided at the time for doing so. Amusingly, this tallies almost precisely with the acclaim Spore received in 2008. this game makes your dreams come true.' An unusual statement, but undoubtedly a positive one.Īll told, 87 percent of Steam’s user reviews of Spore are positive.

' Used to love playing this back in the day,' recalls user Rikimaru, while Pyromancer states, ' Great game, even after 10 years.' User Theondrew is particularly complimentary, stating ' I made a moving penis and make it eat with its balls. At the time of writing, Spore has 14,060 user reviews on Steam, which aggregate to a 'Very Positive' rating. Steam, however, seems to remember things differently. It was the No Man’s Sky of its day, or the Daikatana of the future, another game that dreamed too big and delivered too little. I remember Spore as one of gaming’s most notorious flops, a classic case of a hype bubble that blew too big and then burst spectacularly, covering everyone in a thin and sticky film of anger and resentment.
